Posts

Build a bigger movement

  Build a bigger movement.  Join a bigger movement, and make it even bigger. Many of the problems of leftist movements - or of any movement, for that matter - would probably end up getting solved, or at least greatly improved, if the movement were larger. Is your sect cliquish?  Exclusionary?  Authoritarian?  Is there a lot of corruption, secrecy, sexual impropriety, harassment?  Build a bigger movement.  That dirtbag leader is a big fish in a small pond.  When more and more people vastly outnumber the clique, they will have power in numbers to which the clique will ultimately have to respond.  Inevitably it will become more democratic and open. Is your sect not scientific?  Too ideological, too dogmatic?  Build a bigger movement.  As it becomes larger, more democratic, and more open, this will afford the opportunity for it to become more scientific. Excessive secrecy and protective defensiveness of an inner circle is often a r...
Nietzsche was flat-out wrong when he said, "Without Hegel there could have been no Darwin."  (The Gay Science,  §357)    Darwin was not influenced by Hegel in any way.  Interestingly, he was, however, influenced by Hegel's contemporary, Alexander von Humboldt. On the other hand, Alfred Russel Wallace, who conceived of the process of natural selection almost simultaneously with Darwin, did indeed engage with German philosophy, including Hegel, as well as Alexander von Humboldt, and wound up developing his own quite quirky theology.  T. H. Green and David Georgie Ritchie went even further, with Ritchie claiming that Darwin could not be understood outside a Kantian framework and attempting to synthesize Darwin with Hegel, and I suspect that Darwin's half-cousin, Francis Galton, may have had some German Idealist inspirations as well, although I'm not certain of that. Of course, Nietzsche goes on in the same section to say that "We Germans are Hegelians eve...
If we were going to follow Lenin's lead in starting a revolution, what would that mean?  Let's go through it, step by step: Step 1: Be born the son of a minor aristocrat in a semi-industrialized, yet imperialist and profoundly repressive society with a large yet deeply divided portion of the populace already dedicated to the violent overthrow of the government. Step 2: Wait for a world war. Step 3: When violent overthrow of the government comes (emerging out of anti-war protests), don't have anything to do with it.  Don't even be in the country, or aware of what's happening, but by total coincidence, just happen to be the family friend of the person who comes to be in charge of the new government. Step 4: From the center of imperialism, and later from a neutral country, write abstract theory that almost no one reads, in which you advocate for allowing enemy countries to defeat your country in war.  No one reads this, that is, except for the secret police of the impe...

Another problem with utilitarianism, or group of problems

I don't regard this as the fundamental problem with utilitarianism, but any competent utilitarian will have to deal with this objection at some point.  And to be fair, many of them do. Although, when I read them closely, I often wonder: when a given utilitarian writes about these questions, are they actually answering them, or are they merely brushing them to the side? Utilitarians tend to challenge the values of earlier, more traditional moral systems.  Take, for instance, how utilitarians deal with with the concept of honor.  Utilitarians tend to reject the idea that honor has intrinsic value.  For a utilitarian such as Jeremy Bentham, the only things that have intrinsic value are pleasure and pain.  Bentham admits to the existence of, and even stresses the importance of what he calls the "pleasures of reputation" and the "sanction of public opinion."  But honor, if it is a coherent concept at all in Bentham's eyes, is only a relative value and not an int...

"Better Fewer But Better"

There's nothing so pathetic as when Leninists tell each other "Better fewer but better."  It's so sad.  It's pure cope, for being losers that don't have many friends, and are quickly losing the friends and allies that they do have.  I really think it's essentially pathological.  "Oh, you reject me?  Well that just proves how right I am!"  That kind of pattern of behavior and self-justification and self-delusion does not end well. Build a bigger movement.  Better yet, join a bigger movement.  And then make it even bigger.  Bear in mind that when Lenin said, "Better fewer but better," he was already head of state .  Whenever I see a Leninist loser in America saying "Better fewer but better," I want to say, okay, buddy, take over the state first.  Then you can start talking about how things would be "Better fewer but better." The truth is, even in Lenin's time, "Better fewer but better" was a terrible, hop...
  Hegel's radical idea is that, rather than the conditioned being derived from the unconditioned, instead: the unconditioned arises, and can, necessarily only arise out of the conditioned. That is, reason can only arise from unreason; freedom can only arise from unfreedom. 
  Marxism: an optimism that gradually becomes more and more meaningless. 

Mottos

1. Anything is better than nothing. 2. Whatever works.  3. Build a bigger movement.
The commodity form existed long before capitalism.  I think it existed since at least ancient Sumeria. Bronze age Sumerian society was essentially a factory for producing idols.  How can we discount the commodity fetishism of actual , literal fetishes?

Socialism is the true Libertarianism

  So-called "libertarians are right to assert their rights - to say things like, "So long as it's between consenting adults, people should be able to engage in any kind of sexual activity they want," or "people should be able to do all the recreational drugs they want," and so on.   But they are naive about how to achieve the goal of the kind of free society they imagine. There's an irony here: libertarians often tend to say things like "You can't legislate morality." What's naive about libertarians is that they think that merely by declaring what should be the case - that, for instance, "So long as it's between consenting adults, people should be able to engage in any kind of sexual activity they want," that that's what will happen.  In short, they are trying to legislate morality. In order to establish a libertarian society, it is not enough to imagine, to declare, to wish. To create a free society, one must trans...
You can define the morally good as: that set of behaviors which you have many strong reasons to train others to do, especially through rewarding them with praise.  Similarly, morally bad (or "evil") can be defined as: that set of behaviors which you have many strong reasons to train others not to do, especially through negatively reinforcing them with condemnation. We are all subtly training each other, especially through praise and condemnation.  But especially, parents tend to train children, and in general, older members of a social group train the young.  Thus training can pass down from generation to generation.  But younger people, especially from the ages of about 3 to about 11, are more susceptible to training than older people.  After this point, the rate of acquisition of training slows, and humans may even become resistant to training.  Old people may become very incapable of, or very resistant to, new training.  That might be a bug, or it m...
Every time I see photographs of the Frankfurt School, they look embarrassed.  More than embarrassed: they look ashamed.  It's as if they are ashamed to be an image, ashamed to be visible, ashamed to have bodies, ashamed to have faces.  They wish they were purely a text.
I have said that Hegel's project is the critique of Romanticism.  But what is Romanticism? Trying to define Romanticism is famously difficult.  It resists definition, it defies categorization.  And if anything, it is that resistance. If I could try to describe Romanticism with one word, it would be rebellion.  But of course that's too simplistic.  Romanticism and rebellion are not simply synonyms.  Romantics do not always rebel, and when they rebel, they rebel in a specific way.  The Romantic poet or the Romantic artist usually says something like, "I am a human! I am a person! I am an individual being, with feelings, real feelings!"  Romanticism is a rebellion from the heart, so to speak.  Romantic rebellion is not about taxes or insurance or debt reform or many of the other material things that have historically incited insurrections throughout history.  The Romantic - the Romantic poet, for instance - demands recognition.  Every ...

The most glaring error in Austrian, Neoclassical, and Neoliberal economics

  The most fundamental, glaring error in Austrian economics - as well as Neoclassical, Neoliberal and related forms of economics, including Hayek and much of what passes for "mainstream" economics - is the problem of monopoly and their magical thinking about "perfect competition."  

How I disagree with Yudkowsky

LessWrong began as a blog about how Bayesian statistics is better than frequentism.  I've already written about my opinion about Bayesianism.  Suffice it to say here that although I respect it, I don't think it's as omnipotent as some of its most dogmatic adherents do. I've written a lot on this blog about how much I hate and oppose utilitarianism.  Mostly, this is because I think utilitarianism is unscientific.  It should therefore come as no surprise that I am opposed to "Effective Altruism," which is a recent, and particularly nasty form of utilitarianism.  I don't especially blame Yudkowsky for this - I put the blame much more on Peter Singer and others who founded this movement.  But one must admit that Yudkowsky and his followers did quite stupidly and uncritically go along with this nonsense, and it led them to terrible errors. Some people think that Yudkowsky and his followers are wrong about AI.  But I think they are wrong about humanity ....

Some common sense principles and a radical idea

1. A person should be able to do anything they want to their own body: dress how they want, get whatever piercings or tattoos they want, get any surgery they want, take any medication they want, etc..  A person should also be able to not do anything their own body that they don't want to do. 2. People should should be able to fuck whomever they want, so long as everyone involved is a consenting adult.  Also, obviously, a person should also be able not to fuck anyone they don't want to fuck. 3. No one should be discriminated against, as workers, for any behavior that falls under common sense principles 1 and 2. 4. People should be legally allowed to say whatever they want.  Included in this is: people should be legally allowed to call each other whatever they want, including mean, nasty, rude names.  No one should be discriminated against for exercising their free speech, either - especially outside of work, but even at work, so long as it doesn't interfere wit...

Adam Conover's Conspiracy Theory Doesn't Make Sense

Image
I like Adam Conover.  I've watched him since the CollegeHumor days.  He's funny, he's smart, and I agree with a lot of the stuff he's said in the past.  I'll probably agree with a lot of stuff he says in the future. But recently, he uploaded a video, "AI Existential Risk Was Invented to Distract Us" which seems pretty half-baked.   Now I don't really think that it's very likely that AI will kill everyone.  I think it's much more likely that AI enslave us or make us doglike.  (To see my list of probabilities, click here.)  That said, I don't think it's impossible that AI will kill or hurt a lot of people.  Just unlikely.  And even though it's unlikely, it's important that we take steps to make sure it doesn't happen. But Conover thinks that people like me, who are concerned about this, are just big dummies, suckers, rubes, who have had the wool pulled over our eyes.  According to Conover, we are victims of a conspiracy - a v...

The Problem of Propaganda

  People usually associate propaganda with politics, especially movements like Bolshevism and fascism.  But the term "propaganda," which is a Latin word, was originally used by the Catholic Church, to describe texts written and mass-printed for the propagation of the faith - usually to people of different faiths, who often spoke different languages.  Propaganda has been used by a wide variety of organizations - religious groups, clubs, fraternal organizations, corporations, etc., etc.. Even so, there has been a rich history of debate about propaganda within the political realm, particularly within the world of Marxism - and this debate has a wider application for everything from the fan base of pop stars to organizations of collectors of model trains and beyond. The problem is this: on the one hand, there is theory - pure, highfalutin theory.  But theory can be very complex and difficult to understand.  So, on the other hand, there is often a countermovement to ...

One fundamental problem with Utilitarianism

  Utilitarianism is not essentialist.  But human pleasure is essentialist.  And so is human desire.  Therefore, utilitarianism misses something fundamental (indeed, essential) about human desire and pleasure.
 Fundamentally, liberals believe that everything is detachable.