Posts

  Not only is private language possible, not only is private language actual, not only is Wittgenstein's own writing an example of private language, but anyone who studies Wittgenstein deeply enough will inevitably begin communicating in private language.  Not only will the general public not know what they are talking about, but even other Wittgenstein scholars will cease to understand them.  I'm tempted to say that they will no longer be capable of understanding themselves. ...And yet, as you fall into Wittgensteinism, the transition to private language will be so slow and so subtle, that you will not have any awareness that you are slipping into private language.  Thus it is true that, from the perspective of Wittgensteinism , there is no such thing as private language.  It is like falling into a supermassive black hole: in the reference frame of the person falling in, there is no event horizon - everything occurs normally as they pass through.  It is on...

In Defense of Identity Politics

  A certain tendency (Marxists, largely, and some anarchists, but also many conservatives - what's the diff, amirite?) moralistically berates us and tells us we should avoid "identity politics".  If they weren't such preachy jerks about it, it would actually be kinda sweet.  And of course, they're right - in a perfect world, that would be the morally right thing to do - to totally abolish all identity politics, whatever that means.  A world without identity politics is unimaginable - literally.  But it's sad that identity politics exist.  It's a shame.  It's a nightmare.  I will even go all the way and say that it's a tragedy.  And yet it is a reality.  Identity politics are a kind of vicious cycle, which just gets deeper and deeper, and seems impossible to escape.  There's no way to avoid it.  We can be in denial about identity politics, we can be angry about identity politics, we can be depressed about identity politics, we c...

The Concept of "Tailism": a Stupid Immaterial Abstraction

  The Concept of "Tailism": A Stupid Immaterial Abstraction   A specter is haunting the world: the specter of tailism. The reason that only weirdos use the neologism "tailism" is that it is a useless term which only causes confusion and lack of theoretical rigor whenever it is thrown around.  This movement is accused of "tailing" such-and-such political party.  That party is accused of "tailing" some other tendency.  For instance, many Marxist groups are accused of "tailing" the Democrats.  Meanwhile, Chris Cutrone and the Platypus Society are accused of "tailing" the Republicans.  But what is "tailing"?  What does it mean, to tail?  Upon close examination, the verb "to tail" does not have any material meaning.   To adopt Marx's schema, the apparent phenomenon of "tailing" appears strictly on the level of the superstructure, and never at the material base of society.  The superstructure inclu...
The argument from authority is not a valid philosophical move.  But it can be a persuasive rhetorical move, when appealing to an authority that is revered by the person for whom you are making the argument.  If I cite an authority to bolster my position, it's not because I revere that authority, but because I think you do. (Sometimes the greatest authority that people revere is themselves; and you can use that authority against them as well.)

What is Liberalism?

Come with me on an adventure.  We'll see something bewildering, strange, and difficult to understand or even to identify - precisely because it is so familiar.  Yes, we're going home.  The challenge is to solve that strange riddle: what is liberalism? Liberalism is not the same thing as democracy.  Also, liberalism is not about rights.  Karl Marx believed in rights, and fought hard for democracy, and yet was no liberal.  Liberalism is not about any particular policy or political position, or any particular form of government or any philosophy of government.  It is more fundamental than that.  It is an entire worldview.  Historically, it precedes the development of large-scale democratic nation-states with constitutionally-guaranteed rights by centuries. Well, if liberalism is not about democracy or rights, then what is it about?  It can be difficult to say.  Just close this window for a moment, and try to define liberalism.  It...
  Lenin = aristocracy (the philosopher-king) Stalin = timocracy Khrushchev = plutocracy Gorbachev = democracy Putin = tyranny (This idea just occurred to me.  Not sure if it works.)

The Only Religion in France is the Worship of Language

  The only religion in France is the worship of language.  For most, it is specifically the worship of the French language, but there are some that worship Latin, some that worship Greek, a few that worship Mandarin Chinese, and here and there you can even find some that worship Nambikwara and Tupi-Kagwahiva.  Of course, if you ask them, they will say that all languages are equal, but the implicit privileging of one over another is obvious.