Against Allan Bloom
[I wrote this essay in 2007, while a student in Katie Terezakis's philosophy class at RIT. She nominated me, and I won, the Kearse Prize for it. If I were writing it today, I would probably reword some parts.] When looking at Plato, I find that I am strangely struck dumb. I cannot say anything about him. The form of his writing is unspeakable; one can only speak about the image of his writing, in the interpretations of the moderns, who live under the regime of contemporary democratic power. Post-modernism never happened; we are all still modern, whether we like it or not. The very term post-modernism is an obvious contradiction, whose only meaning is negative, demonstrating through its very form the very impossibility of one’s ever thinking one’s way out of one’s own time. Those who would oppose modernity, from Leo Strauss’s post-doctoral students to Osama bin Laden and his fellow students of Sayyid Qut’b, are all doomed to be thorough...