Posts

The Key to Derrida (The Trace: Derrida and Eliade)

  Historian of religion Mircea Eliade, in his book "The Sacred and the Profane," writes: "It is true that most of the situations assumed by religious man of the primitive societies and archaic civilizations have long since been left behind by history.  But they have not vanished without a trace...." It is this "trace" that haunts all of Derrida's writings.  The "trace" is many things in Derrida's work, but most importantly it is that which marks the absence of metaphysics.  Those who think that Derrida was recklessly and joyfully destroying everything sacred in our culture have misunderstood him entirely.  Derrida was the undead, forever tracing and retracing the mysterious line between the sacred and the profane.  You cannot understand Derrida until you realize that for him, the end of metaphysics - or "closure" of metaphysics, as he liked to say - was a loss , a terrible, painful loss, but more importantly a loss that was neve...

Abolish the Value Form Theory Form!

  I might as well admit it... the way I think about a lot of the issues I discuss on this site was influenced by my exposure to "value form theory" (VFT) - the stream of thought of some mostly obscure, mostly German-speaking theorists who advocate for an obscure, non-Leninist form of Marx's critique of political economy: people like Hans-Georg Backhaus, Helmut Reichelt, Werner Bonefeld, and so on.  There is an overlap between the thinkers that are associated with VFT and those who have been categorized as the prophets of the "Neue Marx-Lektüre" (new reading of Marx), of whom the most famous exponent is Michael Heinrich (whose "An Introduction to the Three Volumes of Marx's Capital" is a must-read, in my opinion).  There are some parallels elsewhere, such as the earlier Russian theorist Isaak Illich Rubin and Japanese thinkers like Kozo Uno and Tomohiko Sekine.  In the English-speaking world, these ideas are popular among people who also have an int...

Mystics and Hubristics

  Continuing from: the Stupidest Idea Certain people believe (or purport to believe) that all thought is in language, that being itself is in language, that "language is the house of being," that nothing escapes language, that "there is nothing outside the text," that, in principle at least, everything is expressible, or at least that everything that is important is expressible and that if anything else remains, we may discard it as irrelevant.  We can call these people "Hubristics." Then, certain other people make language into a kind of villain, and believe not only that the most important truths are ultimately inexpressible, but that one shouldn't try - that attempting to express the inexpressible can only have a corrupting influence, that all representation is corruption, that we should "embrace the silence," that only a pure, unmediated experience is genuinely authentic.  Some go so far as to take a vow of silence.  We can call these pe...

Be Pretentious!

Image
  To pretend is, etymologically, to put one's effort toward something - the Latin tendere is also where we get "tense," "tension," but also "tender."  For most of the history of the English language, a pretender referred exclusively to a person who laid claim to something, usually a noble or royal title - a "pretender to the throne."  Whether or not this claim was true was irrelevant.  A person who really was the heir of the British Monarchy was just as much a "pretender to the throne" as a person who falsely thus claimed.  But later (presumably because the winners write the history books) pretense acquired the connotation of a false, or imaginary, claim of nobility, and finally came to mean imagination itself - the realm of dreams, of hope, of yearning.    Thus a person who shames you for being pretentious is telling you to know your place .  They're telling you not to try to give any creative meaning to your own experience, ...
  We can think about our attitude towards Bayesian statistics along a kind of scale, or a group of related scales, for instance something like this: 1) Bayesian statistics is so wrong-headed that it is more likely to tend towards wrong results than correct results. 2) Bayesian statistics is no help at all in learning about anything.  The results are no better than random processes like rolling dice or a coin flip.  It's utterly worthless.  (Sidenote: this is actually worse than (1).  If (1) were the case, you could always bet against Bayesian statistics and come out on top!  Thus (1) would actually useful!) 3) Bayesian statistics can be one among many tools for gaining certain kinds of relevant knowledge, but it cannot function correctly unless it is used in combination with other conceptual tools. 4) Bayesian statistics is one tool among many, and there are certain specific applications where it becomes possible and useful to use Bayesian statistics withou...

Towards a Goth Politics

Image
    Against Utilitarianism,  Against the Happiness Agenda        "That which produces the common good is always terrible." -Raoul Vaneigem, "The Revolution of Everyday Life"    I was having an online argument with a right-wing, Mises-type ultracapitalist, on the topic of Marxism.  In the course of the conversation, he opined that the problem with Marx's economics was that Marx wrote about maximizing "utils" or "utilons" - that Marx did not realize that human utility cannot be so easily quantitatively measured, since different people subjectively desire different things in different ways.  I almost tore my hair out in frustration.  How do you respond to this kind of ignorance?  How can we have any kind of discussion about economics when people are carrying around these bizarrely inane strawmen? Anyone who was the least bit familiar with Marx's writing would know that Marx would never use such ridiculous terms as "utils" ...

Debord against Communization

Image
    In section 92 of Society of the Spectacle , Debord writes:  "The strength and the weakness of the real anarchist struggle resides in its viewing the goal of proletarian revolution as immediately present [....] From the historical thought of modern class struggles collectivist anarchism retains only the conclusion, and its exclusive insistence on this conclusion is accompanied by deliberate contempt for method. Thus its critique of the political struggle has remained abstract, while its choice of economic struggle is affirmed only as a function of the illusion of a definitive solution brought about by one single blow on this terrain [...]." Criticizing anarchism for its "metaphysics of presence," as it were, Debord has a point.  There are, and have been, anarchists who are, so to speak, "immediatists."  See, for instance, Hakim Bey (most obviously, here , in his book "Immediatism"). But such immediatist anarchists are far from the norm,...